Have a photo? Submit it and we'll credit you.

As an eBay Affiliate, Collector's Key may be compensated if you make a purchase through the link(s) above.

1916-S

Nickels · Buffalo Nickels · 1913–1938
Regular
Weight5 g
Diameter21.2 mm
MintSan Francisco
StrikeCirculation strike
Mintage 11,860,000
EdgePlain
Alignment↑↓ Coin
Composition75% Copper, 25% Nickel
DesignerJames Earle Fraser
Collector's Key IDCK-1276

Collection

collectors own this
on want lists

Your collection

Sign in to track this coin.

About this coinHistory

San Francisco's 1916 Buffalo nickel mintage was 11,860,000 coins, a solid production year that places the 1916-S in the common-date category. The coin is available in circulated grades and accessible in Mint State through major dealer inventories at modest premiums. Strike characteristics continue the pattern of variable quality at San Francisco, with some dies producing sharper detail than others.

Collectors building complete Buffalo nickel sets acquire the 1916-S without extraordinary difficulty. The coin is typical of mid-series San Francisco Buffalo production and is a straightforward acquisition. Well-struck Gem examples command modest premiums but are available through specialist channels at reasonable prices.

The 1916-S represents an improvement over earlier San Francisco Buffalo mintages (1913-1915) in terms of overall availability in high grades. Specialists building comprehensive sets often find the 1916-S one of the easier San Francisco Buffalo nickels to acquire in satisfactory condition before tackling the harder semi-keys and key dates.

Price guideReference

Reference data only — not an appraisal.

GradeDescriptionLowHigh
G-4 Good (G) $10.50 $12
VG-8 Very Good (VG) $14.50 $16.50
F-12 Fine (F) $25 $29
VF-20 Very Fine (VF) $40 $46
EF-40 Extremely Fine (EF) $73 $84
AU-50 About Uncirculated (AU) $116 $134
MS-60 Uncirculated (MS) $183 $210
MS-63 Choice Uncirculated (MS) $320 $340
Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
How much is a 1916-S Buffalo Nickel worth?
In Good condition it runs about $10.50–$12, rising to roughly $183–$210 in Uncirculated. These are reference values, not an appraisal.
How many 1916-S Buffalo Nickels were minted?
11,860,000 were struck.
What is a 1916-S Buffalo Nickel made of?
75% Copper, 25% Nickel, weighing 5 g.
What is the melt value of a 1916-S Buffalo Nickel?
Its melt value is its metal content multiplied by the current spot price. See our melt calculator on the metals pages for a live figure.
Is the 1916-S Buffalo Nickel a key date?
It's a more common date overall, though scarcer die varieties may carry a premium — see the varieties list.